Why Rural Americans Lean Conservative: A Personal Perspective

Living in rural America, I have witnessed firsthand the unique values and perspectives that have shaped the political landscape. My background in a sparsely populated area with small towns and farms has provided me with a distinct viewpoint on why rural Americans tend to lean conservative.

Self-Reliance and Personal Responsibility

The underlying values in rural America are self-reliance and personal responsibility. Unlike in densely populated urban areas, there is no concept of a 'nanny state' or government handouts. Rural residents generally believe in minimal government intervention and prefer to thrive on their own. These values have been ingrained in many generations, making it difficult for people to relate to the causes and beliefs championed by the left.

Despite the challenges, rural Americans manage to sustain their lifestyle and communities effectively. For instance, my experience contrasts sharply with that of many in urban areas, who often lack the self-sufficiency and hands-on experience that is common here. This leads to a strong desire for less government and more autonomy.

Resistance to Outsiders and Cultural Preservation

There is a genuine resistance to outsiders, not because of inherent prejudice, but because of a determination to preserve and sustain their own values. This resistance stems from a belief that change, especially forced change, could undermine the fabric of their communities. For many, being labeled a 'racist' is a mischaracterization as their actions may well reflect core moral values that prioritize helping those in need.

It is important to note that while there are individuals who may hold narrow views, the vast majority are not inherently against people who are different. However, they value consistency in personal beliefs and tend to view political parties as opposing philosophies. This leads to a preference for stability and continuity, which is often aligned with conservative values.

The Farming Perspective: A Case Study in Subsidies and Conservation

One of the most misunderstood aspects of rural life is the concept of government subsidies in farming. I often encounter the argument that “farmers get subsidies!” However, this perspective is economically illiterate. Farming is a volatile industry, and without subsidies, many farmers would not be able to make a sustainable living. The seemingly paradoxical relationship between subsidies and food prices can be better understood when viewed through the lens of risk management.

For example, the auto industry does not have the luxury of only getting paid once a year without any guarantee of a product. In farming, the same risk is present, but subsidies provide a safety net to help farmers weather the unpredictable conditions of their industry. When farmers are not growing crops, it is often necessary to manage this surplus to ensure a stable food supply. This is especially true in lean years when crop yields decline.

I recently wrote a piece on the history of Highway 38, which highlights how roads were built before urban development. These roads are not only critical for commerce and survival but also essential for the distribution of goods, including food. The cost of these roads is shared by all, but the benefit is enjoyed by everyone, including rural residents who rely on these infrastructures to support their communities and livelihoods.

Conclusion

While rural America is often stereotyped and misunderstood, it is a place where deep-rooted values and practical realities shape the political landscape. The desire for self-reliance, personal responsibility, and a focus on stability and continuity explain why many rural Americans lean conservative. It is important to engage with these perspectives respectfully and with an open mind, as they offer valuable insights into the fabric of American society.

About the Author

As someone who has lived in rural America and spent time in densely populated urban areas, I offer a balanced and personal viewpoint. My experiences have shaped my understanding of the rural mindset and its influence on American politics. If you have any questions or comments, please feel free to reach out.