Which Question is Correct: 'How Much Does It Cost' or 'How Much is This'? Unraveling English Grammar

The English language, while rich and varied, is also fraught with nuances that can trip up even the most seasoned speakers. Two common questions, often asked in related contexts, are 'How much does it (or something) cost' and 'How much is this (or that)?' These questions might seem interchangeable, but there are specific rules to follow to ensure grammatical correctness.

Simple Present Tense and Auxiliary Verbs

Both 'cost' and 'is' fall under the simple present tense, but the correct form of auxiliary verbs, 'do' and 'is,' differs based on the subject. In this tense, questions require auxiliary verbs before the subject, dropping the 's' (if any) on the main verb. Thus, the correct questions are 'How much does it cost' or 'What does it cost.'

Common Usage

Commonly, we hear questions such as:

'How much does it cost'

'How much is this'

Both of these questions are grammatically correct, with a slight difference in emphasis. 'How much is this' can be more concise, but 'How much does it cost' is more formal and specific.

Regional and Slang Variations

It is important to note that in some regions and among certain demographics, there may be regional or slang variations. For example, in some places, you might hear 'what it be' or 'whats going on.' However, these are not standard in formal English and should be avoided in professional or academic contexts.

How to Ask About Cost

Physical Items

When asking about the cost of a physical item, the correct question could be addressed as follows:

'How much is this one?' (holding up or pointing to an item)

'What does this one cost?' (holding up or pointing to an item)

These questions are clear and direct.

Non-Tangible Things

For non-tangible items, such as services or tickets, the questions are:

'How much is a haircut?' (service)

'How much is a one-way ticket to Albuquerque?' (ticket)

A simple song mnemonic can help remember proper usage:

How much is it, how much is it, you tell me, you tell me, how much is it that you paid for it?

Present and Past Tense

When considering past or future actions, the questions adjust accordingly. For a past action, you would use 'did':

'How much did it cost?' (referring to a purchase in the past)

This question implies a conversation about an action that is no longer current. For a current or future action, 'does' or 'is' is used:

'How much does it cost?' (referring to a current or future purchase)

Native Speaker Usage

A native English speaker might use simpler, more conversational forms, such as:

'How much is this?' (pointing to an item)

'How much is that?' (pointing to a different item)

'How much are these?' (holding multiple items up)

'How much are those?' (pointing to a group of items)

'How much is it?' (pointing to a single item)

'How much are they?' (holding a group of items up)

'How much?' (to ask in a general sense)

It's advisable to avoid using 'this,' 'that,' 'these,' or 'those' for non-tangible items to maintain clarity.

Summary

Whether you're asking about the cost of a tangible item or a service, understanding the correct auxiliary verbs and usage is key to mastering these questions. In summary, the correct forms are:

'How much does it cost?' (for a physical item or in a formal context)

'How much is this?' (for a physical item in a casual or conversational setting)

.UTC