The Ethical Dilemma of Disrespecting Our Defenders and Authorities

In today's complex world, the ethics of one's personal conduct play a pivotal role. The dishonour and disrespect shown towards any profession or field are alarming. However, disdaining the foundation of our society – the Indian Armed Forces and the Indian Police – is not just unethical but dangerous. It is a stark reminder that such actions don't exist in a vacuum; they have far-reaching consequences that affect the fabric of our nation. This article explores the reasons behind the disrepute and the impact it has on our security and social integrity.

The Historical Context: Disrespect Towards Military Personnel

One of the most notable instances of disrespect towards the Indian military is the reduction in pension for Armed Forces personnel by Smt Indira Gandhi. In the early 1970s, the pension for Armed Forces personnel was reduced from 75% to 50% of their last pay. This move reflects the general treatment of the military by politicians and the bureaucracy, highlighting a systemic issue rather than an isolated incident.

The Ethical Landscape: Blame Game and Responsibility

The blame for this disrespectful treatment can be traced to several entities:

1. The Constitution Makers

The design of the bureaucratic model of governance by the constitution makers has perpetuated a system where power is retained by a few, and the people are seen as subjects rather than citizens. This has led to the systematic undercutting of the Armed Forces. The Secretary Defence is seen as the supreme authority, while the Chiefs of Defence Forces are merely subservient to him. Additionally, the prohibition against Defence Forces forming associations to represent their interests further exacerbates the issue.

2. The Voters

The election of illiterate, incompetent, criminal, and corrupt politicians and political dynasties has divided the country along various faultlines such as religion, language, caste, creed, sham socialism, pseudo secularism, regionalism, and communism. These divisions make it easier for politicians to direct the blame and divert attention from their own misdeeds. As a result, Defence Forces are often expected to obey unethically or even corrupt orders without question. Those who stand up to such authority are often persecuted or removed from their positions.

3. Senior Officers of the Defence Forces

Even within the ranks of the Armed Forces, there is a lack of ethical leadership. Historically, several senior officers have faced neglect, humiliation, and even sacking. For instance, Field Marshal Manekshaw died in penury and neglect, suffering at the hands of the Government of India. Similarly, Admiral Bhagwat and General Sinha faced unjust sacking. The One Rank One Pension agitation further pushed the retired officers and widows to the brink, with harsh treatment and legal battles. The subsequent Central Pay Commissions have consistently reduced the pay and status of soldiers, further eroding their dignity and morale.

The Call for Ethical Responsibility

Ultimately, if we do not value and respect our protectors, we cannot expect to find respect elsewhere. Ethical responsibility is not just a personal choice but a collective duty. It is incumbent upon every citizen, politician, and military leader to uphold the principles of honor and integrity. Only through such actions can we build a society that respects and values its defenders.

In conclusion, the disrespect towards our Armed Forces and Police is not just an issue of ethics; it is a matter of national security and social integrity. By acknowledging and addressing the systemic issues, we can pave the way for a better future for our country.