The Complexity of Crafting a Good Song: Debunking the Myth of Immediate Perfection

Since the early 1960s, the music industry has expected artists and bands to write their own songs. However, with the advent of computer 'music programs' that allow non-musicians to fiddle around with 'Lego rhythm facilities,' we often see a proliferation of songs that lack melody, harmony, and coherence. Sometimes, a phrase is simply repeated throughout the track, resulting in uninspired and uninspiring output.

Challenges in Songwriting

For most people who write song lyrics, books, or pamphlets, the idea of a "first-time perfect" project is a myth. It requires multiple rewrites, often many of them. Even a renowned popular songwriter might find it challenging to achieve a hit on their first attempt. These rewrites can be likened to the meticulous fine-tuning a skilled painter gives to a canvas to capture the magic of the moment.

Revisions Are Part of the Process

If a composer releases a song before it is fully developed, they might be seen as rushing the process, leading to a subpar product. There is no alternative to dedicating the time and effort required to perfect each element, from melody to arrangement.

Personally, I find the process of writing song arrangements incredibly rewarding even if it often demands numerous rewrites. Sometimes, a song will pour out of me effortlessly, but more times than not, it requires careful refinement. Just as an author revises a manuscript to enhance its clarity and impact, so too must a songwriter revisit and revise their work.

Control and Flexibility in Listening

Your experience as a listener stands in stark contrast to that of a songwriter. You have complete control over your auditory experience. All you need to do to stop a song is use a single finger, one little finger, to press the stop button. Alternatively, you can let the song play to your liking, which is much simpler and more straightforward.

Conclusion: Rewriting and Perfection

The ability to rewrite and refine a project is crucial in both writing and music composition. It is a testament to the complexity and depth of the creative process. As songwriters, we must embrace the need for revision to achieve the best possible outcome. The end result is often a more polished and impactful piece, whether it's a book or a song.

So, the next time you appreciate a song that resonates with you, remember that behind every masterpiece lies a journey of numerous rewrites, a journey that ultimately makes the final product all the more valuable.