Reasons Why People Dislike The Trouble with Tribbles - An Analysis

"The Trouble with Tribbles" is one of the most iconic episodes in the Star Trek universe, earning its place among the top 10 episodes. Despite its widespread acclaim, the episode has sparked significant controversy. In this article, we will explore the various reasons why some viewers might dislike this episode, focusing on its portrayal of Klingons, perceived lightheartedness, and the concerns of the show's original creator, Gene Roddenberry.

Why Do People Dislike The Trouble with Tribbles?

One of the most common reasons cited for the dislike of "The Trouble with Tribbles" is the presence of Klingons. Despite their prominent role in later Star Trek series, the heavy-handed portrayal of Klingons in this episode may not have sat well with some viewers. The Kzinti (as seen in the Mirror Universe) were not present, and the Klingons were presented in a less aggressive, more comic relief way than expected. This unexpected departure from the norm may have led to a sense of disappointment or frustration among some fans.

Klingons in the Episode

When asked why they disliked the episode, many pointed to the inclusion of Klingons, especially in their comic relief scenes. The Klingon's role is primarily to provide humor, not aggression, which may have felt out of place to some viewers accustomed to the stern and menacing portrayal of these aliens in subsequent episodes. The episode features scenes with Klingons stealing tricorders, trying to understand the Sonnet, and even sitting on a bench to nap, all of which might have been seen as an unwelcome change to the established character dynamics and narrative tone.

Gene Roddenberry's Perspective

Another major reason for the dislike of "The Trouble with Tribbles" is the involvement of the show's creator, Gene Roddenberry. While he was generally proud of the episode, it is known that he was concerned about the increasing comedic pace of the series. Roddenberry was a firm believer in the seriousness of Star Trek, viewing it as a show that upheld high moral standards and gravitas. When he heard laughter during the filming of this episode, it likely upset him, as he was wary of the show slipping into camp or becoming overly comedic.

In a statement that remains controversial, Roddenberry reportedly expressed dissatisfaction with the episode, leading to the exasperated response, "Gene, I think it's being done too well!" This quote highlights his struggle to balance the serious and comedic elements of the series, and it reflects the tension between maintaining the show's core values and creating an entertaining and engaging episode.

A Recap of Why Nobody Dislikes It

It's important to note that despite these criticisms, "The Trouble with Tribbles" is widely regarded as one of the best episodes in the Star Trek canon. For many fans, the episode remains an enjoyable and memorable part of the series. Even those who dislike it can agree that it has held up well over the years, with its well-paced humor and intricate plot being appreciated by both casual viewers and hardcore Trek enthusiasts.

In conclusion, the reasons why some people might dislike "The Trouble with Tribbles" range from the unexpected portrayal of Klingons to Gene Roddenberry's strict vision for the show. However, it is undeniable that the episode stands as a significant and beloved part of Star Trek's rich history. Whether one loves or dislikes the episode, it is clear that its cultural impact has been profound and lasting.