Navigating the MBTI Maze: Am I an INFP, INTP, or ISTP?

I recently submitted this question because roughly a year ago I began taking MBTI quizzes, and as of 2023, I consistently identify as an ISTP on the 16 Personalities website. Despite getting INTP on some other websites and even INFP, it remains odd that I consistently get ISTP on the same platform, even after repeated attempts and without deliberately aiming for the same answers.

However, I took that quiz again last night, and despite my certainty of the outcome, I was surprised to find myself slightly shifting towards an INTP type. Personally, I identify as an INFP for various reasons. At times, I tend to be quite emotional, to the point where I can cry on my bed before sleeping, as silly as that might sound. While I share these characteristics, the thought of being labeled as a 'crybaby' isn't something I'm particularly proud of. I must admit, I really like Frank James, but this is just one of the many facets of my personality.

ISTP, INTP, and INFP: A Personal Odyssey

The ISTP part of me is somewhat agreeable because I often adopt a conventional demeanor to avoid upsetting those around me, which resonates with my core values. The INTP part of me finds expression in the dedication I put into my creative projects. Recently, I'm working on an album that incorporates multiple genres such as Rock, Soul, Pop, Jazz, and Broadway. Interestingly, there are instances when I score well on exams without studying or reviewing. Moreover, people often describe me as intuitive, which is a trait closely associated with the INTP type.

Understanding Personalities Through a Different Lens

While I appreciate quizzes and categories, I also delve into understanding types from an Evolutionary Psychology perspective. According to this theory, the ISTP herder type and the INTP hunter type have distinctly different evolutionary origins and characteristics. ISTPs are believed to have originated in herder societies, characterized by their practical, grounded, and detail-oriented nature. INTPs, on the other hand, emerged in hunter-gatherer societies, known for their innovation, problem-solving abilities, and strategic thinking.

For instance, the INTP is more likely to feel like an outsider in this world compared to the other types. The farmer type, or ISTJ, is characterized by their hard-working, conscientious, and traditionalist personality. They often have shorter, broader faces and form a more square-like appearance. Each of these types has its unique strengths and challenges, reflecting the diverse role they played in their respective societies.

Further Reading and Insights

If you find the evolutionary types intriguing, I can recommend the book The hunter-gatherer neurotribe: gifted geeks, aspies, and other aliens in this world by Andreas Hofer. This book delves deeper into the psychological traits and characteristics of these types, providing a richer understanding of human behavior and personality.

In conclusion, the journey to understand one's personality is complex and multi-faceted. Whether you identify as an INFP, INTP, or ISTP, each type brings unique insights and challenges to the table. The key is to accept and embrace the multifaceted aspects of your personality, celebrating the quirks and strengths that make you who you are.

Do you resonate with any of these types, or do you fall into a different category altogether? Share your thoughts and experiences in the comments below!