Introduction

My time as a member of Toastmasters International spans more than a decade, during which I have witnessed a myriad of changes within the organization. From the inception of online attendance to the implementation of pathways and the hybrid club model, I have played an active role in shaping various aspects of Toastmasters. Despite these contributions, my overall review of the organization is not one of endorsement. In light of recent developments and my extensive experience, I share these insights, acknowledging that this review is based on personal observations and may not represent the entire organization.

Pros and Cons of Toastmasters International

Pros

Networking and Brand Building: Toastmasters primarily functions as a platform for networking and brand development, which can be invaluable for business and career advancement. Support and Encouragement: For individuals who struggle with public speaking or feel alienated in their personal and professional lives, Toastmasters can provide a supportive environment with an atmosphere of applause and encouragement.

Cons

Overpriced Membership Fees: The cost of membership is disproportionately high, often to the point where the value does not justify the expense. Disregard for Membership Rights: Leadership often overrides the democratic process, taking away membership rights and ignoring the will of the members. Censorship: Members with critical insights or suggestions often face legal threats or confidentiality breaches, stifling open communication and undermining trust. Manipulative Leadership: The top hierarchy abuses their power, playing on the kindness and goodwill of members while manipulating them to serve the organization's interests. Diagnostic Neglect: Despite the organization's commitment to public speaking and personal growth, it often fails to address underlying mental health issues, leading to severe consequences.

Personal Experience and Observations

As a member for over a decade, I have experienced firsthand the organization's shortcomings and the impact it can have on individuals. My contributions ranged from founding hybrid clubs to completing all educational programs. However, my journey with Toastmasters has not been without challenges and disappointments. Here are some specific incidents that highlight the organization's issues:

Toxic Positivity: The culture of toxic positivity can be detrimental to individuals seeking genuine support and guidance. Dictatorial Leadership: The leadership often imposes their will, marginalizing members and creating an environment of fear and obedience. Abuse and Discrimination: The organization has tolerated bullying, sexual harassment, and discrimination, creating a hostile environment for many members. Mismanagement of Funds: The organization seems more focused on profits than on the welfare of its members, often using member contributions for purposes that do not align with the stated goals.

Conclusion

While Toastmasters International has the potential to be a valuable resource for individuals seeking to improve their public speaking skills and build their networks, my personal experience suggests that it falls far short of its stated goals. The organization is riddled with issues such as excessive fees, disregard for member rights, and a culture of manipulation and abuse. If you are considering joining, it is essential to weigh these pros and cons carefully. My recommendation, based on my extensive experience, is to approach Toastmasters International with caution and consider alternative options such as local English corners or other community groups that may offer similar benefits without the drawbacks.