Does a Stubborn Opinion Necessarily Indicate Low Intelligence?

In the digital age, quick changes in opinion or beliefs are often seen as a sign of intelligence and adaptability. However, is it always the case that a person who never changes their opinion must be less intelligent? The answer to this question is not so straightforward and depends on various factors, as I will argue through my experience and observation.

The Complexity of Intelligence and Belief

Firstly, it is crucial to recognize that a person’s opinion is not an isolated trait but is deeply intertwined with their psyche, physical health, and personal principles. Intelligence manifests in many ways, and holding a firm belief that is well-founded and consistently maintained can be a sign of a great mind. Intelligent individuals, by their very nature, tend to stand their ground when they are right, as they have a strong rationale for their positions, backed by data and logical reasoning.

On the other hand, frequent changes in opinion can sometimes reveal a lack of depth in one's understanding. A person who changes their opinion as often as they change their socks might not necessarily demonstrate a high level of intelligence. These changes may merely reflect a lack of introspection and the willingness to be swayed by every new piece of information, which can be more a sign of mental flexibility than intelligence. Conversely, intelligent people are like large rocks in a fast-flowing stream—once they are set, they take considerable effort to be worn away. Like the river, at times, they may even alter course, but it takes significant time and convincing evidence.

The Farrier’s Example

Consider the example of a medieval farrier who lived a long and stable life in the same village. He went to the same church and knew the same community. Despite the world outside his small fold changing, he remained true to his own beliefs and opinions, which may have held since his youth. He might have encountered various travelers and heard about different places and ideas, but these external inputs did not alter his worldview.

Despite this perceived lack of change, the farrier demonstrated remarkable intelligence in other ways. He could craft horseshoes, nails, locks, and keys, among other things, solving practical problems with great skill. He invented tools to address challenges, indicating a keen understanding of technology and mechanics. Just as the architect may design buildings, and the builder constructs them, the farrier showed profound intelligence in his field, even if his opinions remained consistent.

In Conclusion

The assertion that a person with a stubborn opinion necessarily lacks intelligence is a simplification. Intelligence is multifaceted and resilient. Just as a large boulder in a stream retains its form, intelligent individuals can maintain their convictions based on comprehensive understanding and logical reasoning. At the same time, the willingness to change one's opinion in the face of convincing evidence is also a sign of intelligence, as it reflects the ability to reassess and adapt.

Key Points:

Belief and intelligence are interconnected, with intelligence manifesting in various ways, including the ability to hold firm views that are well-evidenced. Consistency in opinion does not necessarily point to low intelligence; it may reflect a deep and grounded understanding. The farrier example shows that maintaining beliefs for a long time can still indicate intelligence, especially in practical problem-solving.

Keywords:

stubborn opinion, intelligence, mental flexibility, viewpoint, belief