Boris Johnson’s Green Plan: A Missed Opportunity for Scotland

In a recent headline-grabbing announcement, Boris Johnson touted his green plan, which was seen by many as a blatant attempt to distract from Brexit details and bolster his political standing. However, is this plan truly beneficial for Scotland, or is it simply a political ploy with little substance?

The Devolution Deal and Scottish Independence

Prime Minister Boris Johnson is not only facing political turbulence but also a renewed push for Scottish independence. With the introduction of his so-called “green plan,” Nicola Sturgeon, Scotland’s First Minister, warned that the UK government’s approach to devolved powers is reminiscent of a “smash and grab” scheme. This could kick-start a reconsideration of the independence referendum and potentially lead to a significant political upheaval.

The plan aims to harness Scotland's resources for green energy and transform the country into a more environmentally conscious nation. However, there is a concern that the benefits of these initiatives will likely be minimal for Scotland, while the implementation risks stripping the region of its autonomy.

Boris Johnson’s Unpopular Green Plan

Boris Johnson’s green initiative includes several ambitious measures, such as:

Offshore Wind: Producing enough offshore wind to power every home in the UK by 2030, supporting up to 60,000 jobs. Hydrogen and Nuclear: Pushing nuclear power, hydrogen, and advanced small nuclear reactors, which could support 10,000 jobs. Electric Vehicles: Phasing out sales of new petrol and diesel cars by 2030 and investing in electric vehicle grants. Public Transport: Making cycling and walking more attractive and investing in zero-emission public transport. Jet Zero and Greener Maritime: Supporting zero-emission planes and ships through research projects. Homes and Public Buildings: Making homes, schools, and hospitals greener, with the goal of installing 600,000 heat pumps by 2028. Carbon Capture: Developing technology to capture and store harmful emissions. Nature: Planting 30,000 hectares of trees annually to restore the natural environment. Innovation and Finance: Making the City of London the global centre of green finance.

While the plan sounds promising, the execution in Scotland seems to overlook the region's unique situation and needs. The Scottish government has been vocal about its concerns, particularly regarding the ownership of land and the involvement of Crown Estates, which raises questions about the feasibility and support for these initiatives.

The Risk of Economic Uncertainty

The implementation of these measures raises several economic and political concerns. For instance, the plan might:

Lead to more jobs being created in the north of Britain rather than in Scotland. Create economic uncertainty by making it economically viable to raise taxes again, particularly in the home counties. Impose greater English control over Welsh and Scottish jobs and industries. Lose substantial subsidies from the EU, leaving Scotland and Wales to fend for themselves. Entrench the notion that Scotland, once independent, might become "England’s backyard."

Given the political climate and the ongoing negotiations regarding Brexit, it seems that Boris Johnson's green plan is more about appearing environmentally responsible than making substantive changes benefitting Scotland. The plan risks alienating Scotland further from the union and fostering a sense of regional disillusionment.

Conclusion

The green plan presented by Boris Johnson lacks a clear and consistent approach, potentially undermining its effectiveness. Whether through placing political pressure or addressing genuine environmental concerns, the plan overpromises and underdelivers, especially in regions like Scotland that are already navigating significant political and economic challenges. As Nicola Sturgeon and others have pointed out, now might be the time for Scotland to consider whether secession and independence are viable alternatives.

For the sake of the environment and the region's well-being, it is crucial that any green initiatives not only align with the needs of the people but also foster genuine collaboration and support within the United Kingdom.